Top Seasons by Colts

Season Games Roster Points
1 2004 16 Peyton Manning (QB), Edgerrin James (RB), Marcus Pollard (TE), Marvin Harrison (WR), Reggie Wayne (Flex), Marvin Harrison (Flex), Mike Vanderjagt (K) 643
2 2000 16 Peyton Manning (QB), Edgerrin James (RB), Marcus Pollard (TE), Marvin Harrison (WR), Jerome Pathon (Flex), Marvin Harrison (Flex), Mike Vanderjagt (K) 501
3 1999 16 Peyton Manning (QB), Edgerrin James (RB), Marcus Pollard (TE), Marvin Harrison (WR), Terrence Wilkins (Flex), Marvin Harrison (Flex), Mike Vanderjagt (K) 475
4 2005 16 Peyton Manning (QB), Edgerrin James (RB), Dallas Clark (TE), Marvin Harrison (WR), Reggie Wayne (Flex), Marvin Harrison (Flex), Mike Vanderjagt (K) 473
5 2003 16 Peyton Manning (QB), Edgerrin James (RB), Marcus Pollard (TE), Marvin Harrison (WR), Reggie Wayne (Flex), Marvin Harrison (Flex), Mike Vanderjagt (K) 469
6 2006 16 Peyton Manning (QB), Joseph Addai (RB), Dallas Clark (TE), Marvin Harrison (WR), Dominic Rhodes (Flex), Reggie Wayne (Flex), Adam Vinatieri (K) 455
7 2009 16 Peyton Manning (QB), Joseph Addai (RB), Dallas Clark (TE), Reggie Wayne (WR), Pierre Garcon (Flex), Reggie Wayne (Flex), Matt Stover (K) 436
8 2018 16 Andrew Luck (QB), Marlon Mack (RB), Eric Ebron (TE), T.Y. Hilton (WR), Nyheim Hines (Flex), Jordan Wilkins (Flex), Adam Vinatieri (K) 425
9 2007 16 Peyton Manning (QB), Joseph Addai (RB), Dallas Clark (TE), Reggie Wayne (WR), Anthony Gonzalez (Flex), Marvin Harrison (Flex), Adam Vinatieri (K) 422
10 2014 16 Andrew Luck (QB), Ahmad Bradshaw (RB), Coby Fleener (TE), T.Y. Hilton (WR), Trent Richardson (Flex), Reggie Wayne (Flex), Adam Vinatieri (K) 400
11 2016 16 Andrew Luck (QB), Robert Turbin (RB), Dwayne Allen (TE), Donte Moncrief (WR), Frank Gore (Flex), T.Y. Hilton (Flex), Adam Vinatieri (K) 369
12 2020 16 Philip Rivers (QB), Jonathan Taylor (RB), Trey Burton (TE), T.Y. Hilton (WR), Nyheim Hines (Flex), Jordan Wilkins (Flex), Rodrigo Blankenship (K) 363
13 2008 16 Peyton Manning (QB), Dominic Rhodes (RB), Dallas Clark (TE), Reggie Wayne (WR), Joseph Addai (Flex), Marvin Harrison (Flex), Adam Vinatieri (K) 363
14 2021 17 Carson Wentz (QB), Jonathan Taylor (RB), Mo Alie-Cox (TE), Michael Pittman (WR), Nyheim Hines (Flex), Michael Pittman (Flex), Michael Badgley (K) 359
15 1959 12 Johnny Unitas (QB), Lenny Moore (RB), (TE), Raymond Berry (WR), Alan Ameche (Flex), Lenny Moore (Flex), (K) 354
16 2010 16 Peyton Manning (QB), Joseph Addai (RB), Jacob Tamme (TE), Austin Collie (WR), Reggie Wayne (Flex), Donald Brown (Flex), Adam Vinatieri (K) 351
17 1958 12 Johnny Unitas (QB), Lenny Moore (RB), (TE), Raymond Berry (WR), Alan Ameche (Flex), Lenny Moore (Flex), (K) 348
18 2001 16 Peyton Manning (QB), Dominic Rhodes (RB), Marcus Pollard (TE), Marvin Harrison (WR), Edgerrin James (Flex), Terrence Wilkins (Flex), Mike Vanderjagt (K) 319
19 2013 16 Andrew Luck (QB), Donald Brown (RB), Coby Fleener (TE), T.Y. Hilton (WR), Trent Richardson (Flex), T.Y. Hilton (Flex), Adam Vinatieri (K) 311
20 2002 16 Peyton Manning (QB), Edgerrin James (RB), Marcus Pollard (TE), Marvin Harrison (WR), Reggie Wayne (Flex), Marvin Harrison (Flex), Mike Vanderjagt (K) 307
21 1965 14 Johnny Unitas (QB), Lenny Moore (RB), John Mackey (TE), Jimmy Orr (WR), Tom Matte (Flex), Raymond Berry (Flex), (K) 260
22 1964 14 Johnny Unitas (QB), Lenny Moore (RB), John Mackey (TE), Raymond Berry (WR), Tom Matte (Flex), Joe Don Looney (Flex), (K) 258
23 1998 16 Peyton Manning (QB), Marshall Faulk (RB), Marcus Pollard (TE), Marvin Harrison (WR), Jerome Pathon (Flex), Marvin Harrison (Flex), Mike Vanderjagt (K) 250
24 1957 12 Johnny Unitas (QB), Lenny Moore (RB), (TE), Raymond Berry (WR), Alan Ameche (Flex), Lenny Moore (Flex), (K) 248
25 2019 16 Jacoby Brissett (QB), Marlon Mack (RB), Jack Doyle (TE), Zach Pascal (WR), Nyheim Hines (Flex), T.Y. Hilton (Flex), Adam Vinatieri (K) 241