Top Seasons by Colts

Season Roster Games Points Per Game
1 2004 Peyton Manning (QB), Edgerrin James (RB), Marcus Pollard (TE), Marvin Harrison (WR), Reggie Wayne (Flex), Brandon Stokley (Flex), Mike Vanderjagt (K), Hunter Smith (P), Raheem Brock (DT), Dwight Freeney (DE), Cato June (LB), Bob Sanders (CB), Mike Doss (S), Robert Mathis (DU) 16 52.8
2 2014 Andrew Luck (QB), Ahmad Bradshaw (RB), Coby Fleener (TE), T.Y. Hilton (WR), Dwayne Allen (Flex), Hakeem Nicks (Flex), Adam Vinatieri (K), Pat McAfee (P), Ricky Jean-Francois (DT), Erik Walden (DE), D'Qwell Jackson (LB), Vontae Davis (CB), Mike Adams (S), Greg Toler (DU) 16 49.7
3 2018 Andrew Luck (QB), Marlon Mack (RB), Eric Ebron (TE), T.Y. Hilton (WR), Nyheim Hines (Flex), Erik Swoope (Flex), Adam Vinatieri (K), Rigoberto Sanchez (P), Denico Autry (DT), Jabaal Sheard (DE), Darius Leonard (LB), Kenny Moore (CB), Malik Hooker (S), Shaquille Leonard (DU) 16 44.7
4 2020 Philip Rivers (QB), Jonathan Taylor (RB), Trey Burton (TE), T.Y. Hilton (WR), Nyheim Hines (Flex), Zach Pascal (Flex), Rodrigo Blankenship (K), Rigoberto Sanchez (P), DeForest Buckner (DT), Justin Houston (DE), Darius Leonard (LB), Kenny Moore (CB), Khari Willis (S), Xavier Rhodes (DU) 16 41.1
5 2005 Peyton Manning (QB), Edgerrin James (RB), Dallas Clark (TE), Marvin Harrison (WR), Reggie Wayne (Flex), Dominic Rhodes (Flex), Mike Vanderjagt (K), Hunter Smith (P), Montae Raegor (DT), Robert Mathis (DE), Cato June (LB), Matt Giordano (CB), Mike Doss (S), Dwight Freeney (DU) 16 40.3
6 2009 Peyton Manning (QB), Joseph Addai (RB), Dallas Clark (TE), Reggie Wayne (WR), Austin Collie (Flex), Pierre Garcon (Flex), Matt Stover (K), Pat McAfee (P), Raheem Brock (DT), Robert Mathis (DE), Tyjuan Hagler (LB), Jacob Lacey (CB), Antoine Bethea (S), Jerraud Powers (DU) 16 40.1
7 2003 Peyton Manning (QB), Edgerrin James (RB), Marcus Pollard (TE), Marvin Harrison (WR), Reggie Wayne (Flex), Brandon Stokley (Flex), Mike Vanderjagt (K), Hunter Smith (P), Montae Raegor (DT), Dwight Freeney (DE), Marcus Washington (LB), Walt Harris (CB), Idrees Bashir (S), Raheem Brock (DU) 16 39.9
8 2007 Peyton Manning (QB), Joseph Addai (RB), Dallas Clark (TE), Reggie Wayne (WR), Anthony Gonzalez (Flex), Marvin Harrison (Flex), Adam Vinatieri (K), Hunter Smith (P), Raheem Brock (DT), Robert Mathis (DE), Tyjuan Hagler (LB), Kelvin Hayden (CB), Antoine Bethea (S), Bob Sanders (DU) 16 39
9 2006 Peyton Manning (QB), Joseph Addai (RB), Dallas Clark (TE), Marvin Harrison (WR), Reggie Wayne (Flex), Dominic Rhodes (Flex), Adam Vinatieri (K), Hunter Smith (P), Raheem Brock (DT), Robert Mathis (DE), Rocky Boiman (LB), Kelvin Hayden (CB), Mike Doss (S), Dwight Freeney (DU) 16 38.6
10 2013 Andrew Luck (QB), Donald Brown (RB), Coby Fleener (TE), T.Y. Hilton (WR), Trent Richardson (Flex), Ahmad Bradshaw (Flex), Adam Vinatieri (K), Pat McAfee (P), Ricky Jean-Francois (DT), Robert Mathis (DE), Jerrell Freeman (LB), Darius Butler (CB), Antoine Bethea (S), Vontae Davis (DU) 16 38.1
11 2021 Carson Wentz (QB), Jonathan Taylor (RB), Mo Alie-Cox (TE), Michael Pittman (WR), Jack Doyle (Flex), T.Y. Hilton (Flex), Michael Badgley (K), Rigoberto Sanchez (P), DeForest Buckner (DT), Kwity Paye (DE), Darius Leonard (LB), Kenny Moore (CB), Khari Willis (S), Shaquille Leonard (DU) 17 37.1
12 2008 Peyton Manning (QB), Dominic Rhodes (RB), Dallas Clark (TE), Reggie Wayne (WR), Joseph Addai (Flex), Marvin Harrison (Flex), Adam Vinatieri (K), Hunter Smith (P), Raheem Brock (DT), Robert Mathis (DE), Tyjuan Hagler (LB), Kelvin Hayden (CB), Antoine Bethea (S), Tim Jennings (DU) 16 36.6
13 2010 Peyton Manning (QB), Joseph Addai (RB), Jacob Tamme (TE), Austin Collie (WR), Pierre Garcon (Flex), Reggie Wayne (Flex), Adam Vinatieri (K), Pat McAfee (P), Eric Foster (DT), Dwight Freeney (DE), Tyjuan Hagler (LB), Kelvin Hayden (CB), Antoine Bethea (S), Jerraud Powers (DU) 16 36.2
14 2000 Peyton Manning (QB), Edgerrin James (RB), Marcus Pollard (TE), Marvin Harrison (WR), Jerome Pathon (Flex), Ken Dilger (Flex), Mike Vanderjagt (K), Hunter Smith (P), Ellis Johnson (DT), Chad Bratzke (DE), Mike Peterson (LB), Mark Thomas (CB), Chad Cota (S), Jason Belser (DU) 16 35.2
15 1999 Peyton Manning (QB), Edgerrin James (RB), Marcus Pollard (TE), Marvin Harrison (WR), Terrence Wilkins (Flex), Ken Dilger (Flex), Mike Vanderjagt (K), Hunter Smith (P), Ellis Johnson (DT), Chad Bratzke (DE), Cornelius Bennett (LB), Tyrone Poole (CB), Chad Cota (S), Mark Thomas (DU) 16 34.8
16 2016 Andrew Luck (QB), Robert Turbin (RB), Dwayne Allen (TE), Donte Moncrief (WR), Frank Gore (Flex), T.Y. Hilton (Flex), Adam Vinatieri (K), Pat McAfee (P), Zach Kerr (DT), Kendall Langford (DE), Robert Mathis (LB), Darius Butler (CB), Mike Adams (S), Vontae Davis (DU) 16 33.1
17 2002 Peyton Manning (QB), Edgerrin James (RB), Marcus Pollard (TE), Marvin Harrison (WR), Reggie Wayne (Flex), Qadry Ismail (Flex), Mike Vanderjagt (K), Hunter Smith (P), Raheem Brock (DT), Dwight Freeney (DE), Mike Peterson (LB), Walt Harris (CB), Idrees Bashir (S), Chad Bratzke (DU) 16 32.1
18 2015 Andrew Luck (QB), Frank Gore (RB), Coby Fleener (TE), Donte Moncrief (WR), T.Y. Hilton (Flex), Andre Johnson (Flex), Adam Vinatieri (K), Pat McAfee (P), T.Y. McGill (DT), Kendall Langford (DE), D'Qwell Jackson (LB), Vontae Davis (CB), Mike Adams (S), Dwight Lowery (DU) 16 31.8
19 2019 Jacoby Brissett (QB), Marlon Mack (RB), Jack Doyle (TE), Zach Pascal (WR), T.Y. Hilton (Flex), Nyheim Hines (Flex), Adam Vinatieri (K), Rigoberto Sanchez (P), Grover Stewart (DT), Justin Houston (DE), Darius Leonard (LB), Pierre Desir (CB), Malik Hooker (S), Shaquille Leonard (DU) 16 31.3
20 2001 Peyton Manning (QB), Dominic Rhodes (RB), Marcus Pollard (TE), Marvin Harrison (WR), Jerome Pathon (Flex), Edgerrin James (Flex), Mike Vanderjagt (K), Hunter Smith (P), Ellis Johnson (DT), Chukie Nwokorie (DE), Mike Peterson (LB), Cory Bird (CB), Chad Cota (S), Chad Bratzke (DU) 16 30
21 1959 Johnny Unitas (QB), Lenny Moore (RB), (TE), Raymond Berry (WR), Alan Ameche (Flex), Jerry Richardson (Flex), (K), (P), Gene Lipscomb (DT), Gino Marchetti (DE), (LB), (CB), (S), Art Donovan (DU) 12 29
22 2023 Gardner Minshew (QB), Jonathan Taylor (RB), Mo Alie-Cox (TE), Michael Pittman (WR), Zack Moss (Flex), Andrew Ogletree (Flex), Matt Gay (K), Rigoberto Sanchez (P), DeForest Buckner (DT), Dayo Odeyingbo (DE), Zaire Franklin (LB), Kenny Moore (CB), Julian Blackmon (S), Kwity Paye (DU) 17 28.6
23 2012 Andrew Luck (QB), Delone Carter (RB), Dwayne Allen (TE), T.Y. Hilton (WR), Reggie Wayne (Flex), Donnie Avery (Flex), Adam Vinatieri (K), Pat McAfee (P), Fili Moala (DT), Robert Mathis (DE), Jerrell Freeman (LB), Darius Butler (CB), Antoine Bethea (S), Vontae Davis (DU) 16 25.2
24 1964 Johnny Unitas (QB), Lenny Moore (RB), John Mackey (TE), Raymond Berry (WR), Jimmy Orr (Flex), Joe Don Looney (Flex), (K), (P), (DT), Gino Marchetti (DE), Steve Stonebreaker (LB), Bobby Boyd (CB), (S), Ordell Braase (DU) 14 24.9
25 1958 Johnny Unitas (QB), Lenny Moore (RB), (TE), Raymond Berry (WR), Alan Ameche (Flex), (Flex), (K), (P), Art Donovan (DT), Gino Marchetti (DE), (LB), (CB), (S), Ordell Braase (DU) 12 24.2