Top Seasons by Colts Defenses

Season Roster Games Points Per Game
1 2014 Ricky Jean-Francois (DT), Erik Walden (DE), D'Qwell Jackson (LB), Vontae Davis (CB), Mike Adams (S), Greg Toler (DU) 16 19.94
2 2013 Ricky Jean-Francois (DT), Robert Mathis (DE), Jerrell Freeman (LB), Darius Butler (CB), Antoine Bethea (S), Vontae Davis (DU) 16 18.13
3 2020 DeForest Buckner (DT), Justin Houston (DE), Darius Leonard (LB), Kenny Moore (CB), Khari Willis (S), Xavier Rhodes (DU) 16 16.19
4 2018 Denico Autry (DT), Jabaal Sheard (DE), Darius Leonard (LB), Kenny Moore (CB), Malik Hooker (S), Shaquille Leonard (DU) 16 15.63
5 2015 T.Y. McGill (DT), Kendall Langford (DE), D'Qwell Jackson (LB), Vontae Davis (CB), Mike Adams (S), Dwight Lowery (DU) 16 15.44
6 2021 DeForest Buckner (DT), Kwity Paye (DE), Darius Leonard (LB), Kenny Moore (CB), Khari Willis (S), Shaquille Leonard (DU) 17 15.18
7 2019 Grover Stewart (DT), Justin Houston (DE), Darius Leonard (LB), Pierre Desir (CB), Malik Hooker (S), Shaquille Leonard (DU) 16 14.81
8 2002 Raheem Brock (DT), Dwight Freeney (DE), Mike Peterson (LB), Walt Harris (CB), Idrees Bashir (S), Chad Bratzke (DU) 16 14.38
9 2023 DeForest Buckner (DT), Dayo Odeyingbo (DE), Zaire Franklin (LB), Kenny Moore (CB), Julian Blackmon (S), Kwity Paye (DU) 17 13.53
10 2024 Grover Stewart (DT), Laiatu Latu (DE), Zaire Franklin (LB), Jaylon Jones (CB), Nick Cross (S), Kenny Moore (DU) 11 13.18
11 2004 Raheem Brock (DT), Dwight Freeney (DE), Cato June (LB), Bob Sanders (CB), Mike Doss (S), Robert Mathis (DU) 16 13.06
12 2008 Raheem Brock (DT), Robert Mathis (DE), Tyjuan Hagler (LB), Kelvin Hayden (CB), Antoine Bethea (S), Tim Jennings (DU) 16 12.5
13 2005 Montae Raegor (DT), Robert Mathis (DE), Cato June (LB), Matt Giordano (CB), Mike Doss (S), Dwight Freeney (DU) 16 12.5
14 2009 Raheem Brock (DT), Robert Mathis (DE), Tyjuan Hagler (LB), Jacob Lacey (CB), Antoine Bethea (S), Jerraud Powers (DU) 16 12.38
15 2022 DeForest Buckner (DT), Yannick Ngakoue (DE), Zaire Franklin (LB), Stephon Gilmore (CB), Rodney McLeod (S), Rodney Thomas (DU) 17 11.71
16 2007 Raheem Brock (DT), Robert Mathis (DE), Tyjuan Hagler (LB), Kelvin Hayden (CB), Antoine Bethea (S), Bob Sanders (DU) 16 11.5
17 2003 Montae Raegor (DT), Dwight Freeney (DE), Marcus Washington (LB), Walt Harris (CB), Idrees Bashir (S), Raheem Brock (DU) 16 11.5
18 2010 Eric Foster (DT), Dwight Freeney (DE), Tyjuan Hagler (LB), Kelvin Hayden (CB), Antoine Bethea (S), Jerraud Powers (DU) 16 11.44
19 2012 Fili Moala (DT), Robert Mathis (DE), Jerrell Freeman (LB), Darius Butler (CB), Antoine Bethea (S), Vontae Davis (DU) 16 10.88
20 2017 Hassan Ridgeway (DT), Barkevious Mingo (DE), John Simon (LB), Rashaan Melvin (CB), Matthias Farley (S), Pierre Desir (DU) 16 10.38
21 2011 Ricardo Mathews (DT), Robert Mathis (DE), Pat Angerer (LB), Jacob Lacey (CB), Antoine Bethea (S), Jerraud Powers (DU) 16 10.38
22 2006 Raheem Brock (DT), Robert Mathis (DE), Rocky Boiman (LB), Kelvin Hayden (CB), Mike Doss (S), Dwight Freeney (DU) 16 9.38
23 2016 Zach Kerr (DT), Kendall Langford (DE), Robert Mathis (LB), Darius Butler (CB), Mike Adams (S), Vontae Davis (DU) 16 9
24 2001 Ellis Johnson (DT), Chukie Nwokorie (DE), Mike Peterson (LB), Cory Bird (CB), Chad Cota (S), Chad Bratzke (DU) 16 8.81
25 1999 Ellis Johnson (DT), Chad Bratzke (DE), Cornelius Bennett (LB), Tyrone Poole (CB), Chad Cota (S), Mark Thomas (DU) 16 8