All Time Colts Team
All Time Colts
| Position |
Player |
Span |
S |
G |
Per Game |
Per Season |
Best Season |
| QB |
Peyton Manning |
1998-2011 |
14 |
208 |
5.42 |
80.57 |
218 |
| RB |
Lenny Moore |
1956-1967 |
10 |
118 |
3.66 |
43.20 |
98 |
| TE |
Dallas Clark |
2003-2011 |
9 |
115 |
2.30 |
29.33 |
66 |
| WR |
Marvin Harrison |
1996-2008 |
13 |
190 |
3.92 |
57.23 |
90 |
| WR |
Reggie Wayne |
2001-2014 |
14 |
211 |
2.22 |
33.43 |
72 |
| WR |
Raymond Berry |
1955-1967 |
13 |
154 |
2.62 |
31.08 |
84 |
| K |
Adam Vinatieri |
2006-2019 |
14 |
205 |
6.44 |
94.36 |
137 |
| P |
Hunter Smith |
1999-2008 |
10 |
160 |
1.15 |
18.40 |
23 |
| LS |
Matt Overton |
2012-2016 |
5 |
80 |
2.90 |
46.45 |
60.64 |
| C |
Jeff Saturday |
1999-2012 |
14 |
211 |
2.17 |
32.66 |
49.28 |
| G |
Jake Scott |
2004-2007 |
4 |
60 |
2.75 |
41.24 |
42.24 |
| G |
Jim Parker |
1962-1967 |
5 |
59 |
2.44 |
28.80 |
42 |
| T |
Tarik Glenn |
1998-2006 |
9 |
138 |
2.33 |
35.78 |
59.32 |
| T |
Ryan Diem |
2003-2010 |
8 |
115 |
2.57 |
36.94 |
56.32 |
| DT |
Raheem Brock |
2002-2009 |
6 |
88 |
1.60 |
23.50 |
36 |
| DT |
Ellis Johnson |
1995-2001 |
6 |
92 |
1.20 |
18.33 |
24 |
| DE |
Robert Mathis |
2003-2013 |
11 |
163 |
3.05 |
45.18 |
77 |
| DE |
Dwight Freeney |
2002-2012 |
11 |
163 |
2.49 |
36.91 |
60 |
| LB |
Darius Leonard |
2018-2021 |
3 |
42 |
4.02 |
56.33 |
64 |
| LB |
Jerrell Freeman |
2012-2015 |
4 |
57 |
2.56 |
36.50 |
66 |
| CB |
Bobby Boyd |
1960-1968 |
9 |
121 |
2.50 |
33.56 |
48 |
| CB |
Vontae Davis |
2012-2017 |
6 |
76 |
3.80 |
48.17 |
107 |
| CB |
Eugene Daniel |
1984-1996 |
13 |
198 |
0.96 |
14.62 |
42 |
| S |
Antoine Bethea |
2006-2013 |
8 |
123 |
1.96 |
30.13 |
41 |
| S |
Mike Prior |
1987-1992 |
6 |
86 |
1.97 |
28.17 |
41 |