| 2023 |
J. Allen QB Bills |
J. Harbaugh HC Ravens |
C. McCaffrey RB 49ers |
D. Bland CB Cowboys |
A. Witherspoon CB Rams |
| 2022 |
P. Mahomes QB KCFT |
A. Reid HC KCFT |
J. Williams RB Lions |
T. Woolen CB Seahawks |
J. Alexander CB Packers |
| 2021 |
A. Rodgers QB Packers |
M. LaFleur HC Packers |
A. Ekeler RB Chargers |
T. Diggs CB Cowboys |
J. Mixon RB Bengals |
| 2020 |
A. Rodgers QB Packers |
A. Reid HC KCFT |
A. Kamara RB Saints |
X. Howard CB Dolphins |
B. Roethlisberger QB Steelers |
| 2019 |
L. Jackson QB Ravens |
J. Harbaugh HC Ravens |
C. McCaffrey RB Panthers |
S. Gilmore CB Patriots |
J. Garoppolo QB 49ers |
| 2018 |
P. Mahomes QB KCFT |
S. Payton HC Saints |
T. Gurley RB Rams |
K. Fuller CB Bears |
A. Luck QB Colts |
| 2017 |
T. Taylor QB Bills |
D. Pederson HC Eagles |
T. Gurley RB Rams |
D. Slay CB Lions |
J. Poyer S Bills |
| 2016 |
A. Rodgers QB Packers |
B. Belichick HC Patriots |
D. Johnson RB Cardinals |
B. Grimes CB Buccaneers |
J. Nelson WR Packers |
| 2015 |
C. Newton QB Panthers |
R. Rivera HC Panthers |
A. Robinson WR Jaguars |
M. Peters CB KCFT |
C. Palmer QB Cardinals |
| 2014 |
T. Brady QB Patriots |
P. Carroll HC Seahawks |
D. Bryant WR Cowboys |
V. Davis CB Colts |
J. Maclin WR Eagles |
| 2013 |
P. Manning QB Broncos |
P. Carroll HC Seahawks |
J. Charles RB KCFT |
K. Dansby LB Cardinals |
D. Smith LB Ravens |
| 2012 |
D. Brees QB Saints |
J. Fox HC Broncos |
A. Foster RB Texans |
R. Sherman CB Seahawks |
P. Manning QB Broncos |
| 2011 |
D. Brees QB Saints |
M. McCarthy HC Packers |
L. McCoy RB Eagles |
B. Browner CB Seahawks |
P. Burress WR Jets |
| 2010 |
P. Manning QB Colts |
B. Belichick HC Patriots |
A. Foster RB Texans |
B. Grimes CB Falcons |
B. Lloyd WR Broncos |
| 2009 |
T. Brady QB Patriots |
J. Caldwell HC Colts |
A. Peterson RB Vikings |
D. Revis CB Jets |
T. Brady QB Patriots |
| 2008 |
P. Manning QB Colts |
J. Fisher HC Titans |
D. Williams RB Panthers |
E. Reed S Ravens |
A. Bryant WR Buccaneers |
| 2007 |
T. Brady QB Patriots |
B. Belichick HC Patriots |
R. Moss WR Patriots |
A. Cromartie CB Chargers |
K. Warner QB Cardinals |
| 2006 |
P. Manning QB Colts |
M. Schottenheimer HC Chargers |
L. Tomlinson RB Chargers |
A. Samuel CB Patriots |
C. Woodson CB Packers |
| 2005 |
C. Palmer QB Bengals |
T. Dungy HC Colts |
S. Alexander RB Seahawks |
C. Bailey CB Broncos |
T. Law CB Jets |
| 2004 |
P. Manning QB Colts |
B. Cowher HC Steelers |
S. Alexander RB Seahawks |
E. Reed S Ravens |
B. Kelly CB Buccaneers |
| 2003 |
J. Blake QB Cardinals |
B. Belichick HC Patriots |
P. Holmes RB KCFT |
T. Law CB Patriots |
J. Woods S KCFT |
| 2002 |
P. Manning QB Colts |
A. Reid HC Eagles |
P. Holmes RB KCFT |
B. Kelly CB Buccaneers |
S. Barber LB Eagles |
| 2001 |
J. Garcia QB 49ers |
M. Martz HC Rams |
M. Faulk RB Rams |
R. Barber CB Buccaneers |
H. Nickerson LB Jaguars |
| 2000 |
P. Manning QB Colts |
J. Fisher HC Titans |
M. Faulk RB Rams |
D. Abraham CB Buccaneers |
R. Harrison S Chargers |
| 1999 |
K. Warner QB Rams |
T. Coughlin HC Jaguars |
S. Davis RB Commanders |
D. Abraham CB Buccaneers |
I. Bruce WR Rams |
| 1998 |
S. Jackson CB Titans |
D. Green HC Vikings |
T. Davis RB Broncos |
J. Hitchcock CB Vikings |
R. Cunningham QB Vikings |
| 1997 |
G. Walker DT Titans |
M. Schottenheimer HC KCFT |
K. Abdul-Jabbar RB Dolphins |
M. McMillian CB KCFT |
A. Rison WR KCFT |
| 1996 |
V. Testaverde QB Ravens |
M. Holmgren HC Packers |
T. Allen RB Commanders |
T. Braxton S Broncos |
R. Woodson CB Steelers |
| 1995 |
E. Kramer QB Bears |
M. Schottenheimer HC KCFT |
E. Smith RB Cowboys |
B. Paup DE Bills |
E. Kramer QB Bears |
| 1994 |
S. Young QB 49ers |
G. Seifert HC 49ers |
E. Smith RB Cowboys |
R. Buchanan S Colts |
D. Marino QB Dolphins |
| 1993 |
S. Humphries QB Chargers |
J. Johnson HC Cowboys |
J. Rice WR 49ers |
E. Allen CB Eagles |
J. Lageman DE Jets |
| 1992 |
D. Marino QB Dolphins |
G. Seifert HC 49ers |
E. Smith RB Cowboys |
H. Jones S Bills |
B. Smith DE Bills |
| 1991 |
J. Harbaugh QB Bears |
J. Gibbs HC Commanders |
B. Sanders RB Lions |
P. Swilling DE Saints |
M. Tice TE Seahawks |
| 1990 |
W. Moon QB Oilers |
G. Seifert HC 49ers |
B. Sanders RB Lions |
W. Haddix CB Buccaneers |
R. Mayes RB Saints |
| 1989 |
W. Moon QB Oilers |
G. Seifert HC 49ers |
J. Rice WR 49ers |
C. Doleman DE Vikings |
M. Merriweather LB Vikings |
| 1988 |
D. White QB Cowboys |
S. Wyche HC Bengals |
G. Bell RB Rams |
C. Lee CB Vikings |
G. Bell RB Rams |
| 1987 |
D. Marino QB Dolphins |
B. Walsh HC 49ers |
J. Rice WR 49ers |
R. White DE Eagles |
J. Anderson LB Packers |
| 1986 |
D. Marino QB Dolphins |
B. Parcells HC Giants |
G. Rogers RB Commanders |
R. Lott S 49ers |
J. Plunkett QB Raiders |
| 1985 |
S. DeBerg QB Buccaneers |
M. Ditka HC Bears |
J. Morris RB Giants |
R. Dent DE Bears |
B. Johnson WR Falcons |
| 1984 |
D. Marino QB Dolphins |
B. Walsh HC 49ers |
M. Clayton WR Dolphins |
K. Easley S Seahawks |
J. Stallworth WR Steelers |
| 1983 |
J. Ferguson QB Bills |
J. Gibbs HC Commanders |
J. Riggins RB Commanders |
K. Riley CB Bengals |
B. Sipe QB Browns |
| 1982 |
D. Casper TE Oilers |
J. Gibbs HC Commanders |
M. Allen RB Raiders |
E. Walls CB Cowboys |
R. Francis TE 49ers |
| 1981 |
D. Williams QB Buccaneers |
B. Walsh HC 49ers |
C. Muncie RB Chargers |
J. Harris S Seahawks |
W. Tyler RB Rams |
| 1980 |
S. Bartkowski QB Falcons |
T. Landry HC Cowboys |
J. Jefferson WR Chargers |
L. Hayes CB Raiders |
B. Chandler WR Raiders |
| 1979 |
J. Zorn QB Seahawks |
C. Noll HC Steelers |
E. Campbell RB Oilers |
L. Hayes CB Raiders |
C. Humphrey DE Eagles |
| 1978 |
B. Sipe QB Browns |
C. Noll HC Steelers |
D. Sims RB Seahawks |
A. Baker DE Lions |
D. Fouts QB Chargers |
| 1977 |
B. Chandler WR Bills |
T. Landry HC Cowboys |
N. Moore WR Dolphins |
H. Martin DE Cowboys |
J. Barkum TE Jets |
| 1976 |
B. Sipe QB Browns |
J. Madden HC Raiders |
C. Branch WR Raiders |
C. Bacon DE Bengals |
P. Warfield WR Browns |
| 1975 |
M. Strachan RB Saints |
B. Grant HC Vikings |
O. Simpson RB Bills |
M. Blount CB Steelers |
B. Bryant CB Vikings |
| 1974 |
A. Manning QB Saints |
J. Madden HC Raiders |
C. Foreman RB Vikings |
E. Thomas CB KCFT |
C. West S Lions |
| 1973 |
A. Manning QB Saints |
B. Grant HC Vikings |
H. Jackson WR Rams |
D. Anderson S Dolphins |
B. Griese QB Dolphins |
| 1972 |
C. Garrett RB Patriots |
D. Shula HC Dolphins |
E. Boozer RB Jets |
J. Gregory DE Giants |
T. Nobis LB Falcons |
| 1971 |
J. Robinson S Texans |
B. Grant HC Vikings |
D. Thomas RB Cowboys |
K. Houston S Oilers |
T. Matte RB Colts |
| 1970 |
J. Robinson S Texans |
B. Grant HC Vikings |
M. Lane RB Cardinals |
L. Barney CB Lions |
W. Wells WR Raiders |
| 1969 |
A. Denson WR Broncos |
J. Madden HC Raiders |
L. Rentzel WR Cowboys |
M. Renfro S Cowboys |
G. Collins WR Browns |
| 1968 |
A. Denson WR Broncos |
D. Shula HC Colts |
L. Kelly RB Browns |
D. Jones DE Rams |
B. Munson QB Lions |
| 1967 |
A. Denson WR Broncos |
J. Rauch HC Raiders |
H. Jones WR Giants |
L. Barney CB Lions |
B. Swain LB Giants |
| 1966 |
W. Carlton RB Bills |
V. Lombardi HC Packers |
L. Kelly RB Browns |
L. Wilson S Cardinals |
D. Hackbart S Vikings |
| 1965 |
D. Hoak RB Steelers |
B. Collier HC Browns |
J. Brown RB Browns |
H. Adderley CB Packers |
|
| 1964 |
S. Jurgensen QB Commanders |
D. Shula HC Colts |
L. Moore RB Colts |
P. Krause S Commanders |
J. Crow RB Cardinals |
| 1963 |
S. Jurgensen QB Eagles |
G. Halas HC Bears |
G. Collins WR Browns |
J. Katcavage DE Giants |
|
| 1962 |
B. Mitchell RB Commanders |
V. Lombardi HC Packers |
J. Taylor RB Packers |
J. Katcavage DE Giants |
F. Gifford RB Giants |
| 1961 |
C. Johnson QB Cardinals |
HC |
P. Hornung RB Packers |
G. Lipscomb DT Steelers |
|
| 1960 |
M. Reynolds QB Commanders |
B. Shaw HC Eagles |
P. Hornung RB Packers |
J. Shofner CB Browns |
|
| 1959 |
B. Layne QB Steelers |
J. Howell HC Giants |
R. Berry WR Colts |
N. Lane CB Cardinals |
|
| 1958 |
E. LeBaron QB Commanders |
J. Howell HC Giants |
J. Brown RB Browns |
J. Butler S Steelers |
B. Wade QB Rams |
| 1957 |
L. McHan QB Cardinals |
P. Brown HC Browns |
L. Moore RB Colts |
J. Christiansen S Lions |
|
| 1956 |
A. Dorow QB Commanders |
P. Driscoll HC Bears |
B. Howton WR Packers |
Y. Lary S Lions |
Y. Lary S Lions |
| 1955 |
O. Graham QB Browns |
P. Brown HC Browns |
A. Ameche RB Colts |
B. Dillon S Packers |
M. Motley RB Steelers |
| 1954 |
J. Finks QB Steelers |
B. Parker HC Lions |
B. Walston WR Eagles |
N. Lane CB Cardinals |
|
| 1953 |
Y. Tittle QB 49ers |
P. Brown HC Browns |
P. Pihos WR Eagles |
J. Christiansen S Lions |
B. Dudley RB Steelers |
| 1952 |
B. Celeri QB Texans |
H. Pool HC Rams |
C. Box WR Lions |
N. Lane CB Rams |
|
| 1951 |
B. Dudley RB Steelers |
P. Brown HC Browns |
E. Hirsch WR Rams |
E. Tunnel CB Giants |
|
| 1950 |
G. Ratterman QB Yanks |
P. Brown HC Browns |
C. Box WR Lions |
E. Tunnel CB Giants |
F. Filchock RB Colts |
| 1949 |
S. Baugh QB Commanders |
G. Neale HC Eagles |
P. Harder RB Cardinals |
E. Tunnel CB Giants |
|
| 1948 |
C. Conerly QB Giants |
HC |
P. Harder RB Cardinals |
E. Tunnel CB Giants |
|
| 1947 |
B. Dudley RB Steelers |
HC |
S. Van Buren RB Eagles |
|
G. McAfee RB Bears |
| 1946 |
G. Dobbs QB Dodgers |
HC |
E. Hirsch RB Rockets |
|
B. Pritchard RB Eagles |
| 1945 |
B. Dudley RB Steelers |
A. Walsh HC Rams |
D. Hutson WR Packers |
E. Sprinkle DE Bears |
K. Kavanaugh WR Bears |
| 1944 |
D. Hutson WR Packers |
S. Owen HC Giants |
S. Van Buren RB Eagles |
E. Sprinkle DE Bears |
F. Filchock QB Commanders |
| 1943 |
M. Goldberg RB Cardinals |
C. Lambeau HC Packers |
D. Hutson WR Packers |
|
B. Osmanski RB Bears |
| 1942 |
B. Dudley RB Steelers |
R. Flaherty HC Commanders |
D. Hutson WR Packers |
|
J. Benton WR Rams |
| 1941 |
A. Farkas RB Commanders |
C. Lambeau HC Packers |
D. Hutson WR Packers |
S. Johnson LB Packers |
|
| 1940 |
T. Thompson QB Steelers |
R. Flaherty HC Commanders |
D. Hutson WR Packers |
S. Johnson LB Packers |
|
| 1939 |
J. Carter WR Eagles |
S. Owen HC Giants |
A. Farkas RB Commanders |
|
|
| 1938 |
B. Feathers RB Dodgers |
S. Owen HC Giants |
D. Hutson WR Packers |
|
|
| 1937 |
J. Drake RB Rams |
G. Halas HC Bears |
C. Hinkle RB Packers |
|
|
| 1936 |
C. Battles RB Patriots |
C. Lambeau HC Packers |
D. Clark RB Lions |
|
B. Nagurski RB Bears |
| 1935 |
K. Strong RB Giants |
S. Owen HC Giants |
D. Clark RB Lions |
|
|
| 1934 |
C. Battles RB Patriots |
G. Halas HC Bears |
D. Clark RB Lions |
|
|
| 1933 |
C. Battles RB Patriots |
S. Owen HC Giants |
K. Strong RB Giants |
|
|
| 1932 |
J. Grossman RB Dodgers |
C. Lambeau HC Packers |
D. Clark RB Spartans |
|
|
| 1931 |
K. Strong RB Stapletons |
C. Lambeau HC Packers |
J. Blood RB Packers |
|
R. Flaherty WR Giants |
| 1930 |
K. Strong RB Stapletons |
R. Andrews HC Giants |
J. McBride RB Dodgers |
|
|
| 1929 |
K. Strong RB Stapletons |
R. Andrews HC Giants |
R. Flaherty WR Giants |
|
R. Grange RB Bears |
| 1928 |
V. Lewellen RB Packers |
E. Weir HC Yellow Jackets |
P. Driscoll RB Bears |
|
J. Thorpe RB Cardinals |
| 1927 |
E. Nevers RB Eskimos |
E. Potteiger HC Giants |
J. McBride RB Giants |
|
J. Sternaman QB Bears |
| 1926 |
E. Nevers RB Eskimos |
G. Chamberlin HC Yellow Jackets |
P. Driscoll RB Bears |
|
|
| 1925 |
J. McBride RB Giants |
N. Barry HC Cardinals |
P. Driscoll RB Cardinals |
|
P. Pearce QB Steam Rollers |
| 1924 |
P. Driscoll RB Cardinals |
P. Berryman HC Yellow Jackets |
B. Rapp RB Panhandles |
|
|
| 1923 |
P. Driscoll RB Cardinals |
G. Chamberlin HC Bulldogs |
D. Sternaman RB Bears |
|
|
| 1922 |
B. Rapp RB Panhandles |
G. Chamberlin HC Bulldogs |
P. Driscoll RB Cardinals |
|
|
| 1921 |
D. Sternaman RB Bears |
HC |
J. Guyon RB Multiple |
|
|
| 1920 |
G. Chamberlin WR Bulldogs |
HC |
J. Guyon RB Bulldogs |
|
|