Top Seasons by Colts Defenses

Season Roster Games Points Per Game
1 2014 Erik Walden (DT), Ricky Jean-Francois (DE), D'Qwell Jackson (LB), Vontae Davis (CB), Mike Adams (S), Greg Toler (DU) 16 19.94
2 2013 Robert Mathis (DT), Ricky Jean-Francois (DE), Jerrell Freeman (LB), Darius Butler (CB), Antoine Bethea (S), Vontae Davis (DU) 16 18.13
3 2020 Justin Houston (DT), DeForest Buckner (DE), Darius Leonard (LB), Kenny Moore (CB), Khari Willis (S), Xavier Rhodes (DU) 16 16.19
4 2018 Jabaal Sheard (DT), Denico Autry (DE), Darius Leonard (LB), Kenny Moore (CB), Malik Hooker (S), Shaquille Leonard (DU) 16 15.63
5 2015 Kendall Langford (DT), T.Y. McGill (DE), D'Qwell Jackson (LB), Vontae Davis (CB), Mike Adams (S), Dwight Lowery (DU) 16 15.44
6 2021 Kwity Paye (DT), DeForest Buckner (DE), Darius Leonard (LB), Kenny Moore (CB), Khari Willis (S), Shaquille Leonard (DU) 17 15.18
7 2019 Justin Houston (DT), Grover Stewart (DE), Darius Leonard (LB), Pierre Desir (CB), Malik Hooker (S), Shaquille Leonard (DU) 16 14.81
8 2002 Dwight Freeney (DT), Raheem Brock (DE), Mike Peterson (LB), Walt Harris (CB), Idrees Bashir (S), Chad Bratzke (DU) 16 14.38
9 2025 Laiatu Latu (DT), Grover Stewart (DE), Zaire Franklin (LB), Kenny Moore (CB), Camryn Bynum (S), Mekhi Blackmon (DU) 10 14.1
10 2023 Dayo Odeyingbo (DT), DeForest Buckner (DE), Zaire Franklin (LB), Kenny Moore (CB), Julian Blackmon (S), Kwity Paye (DU) 17 13.53
11 2004 Dwight Freeney (DT), Raheem Brock (DE), Cato June (LB), Bob Sanders (CB), Mike Doss (S), Robert Mathis (DU) 16 13.06
12 2008 Robert Mathis (DT), Raheem Brock (DE), Tyjuan Hagler (LB), Kelvin Hayden (CB), Antoine Bethea (S), Tim Jennings (DU) 16 12.5
13 2005 Robert Mathis (DT), Montae Raegor (DE), Cato June (LB), Matt Giordano (CB), Mike Doss (S), Dwight Freeney (DU) 16 12.5
14 2009 Robert Mathis (DT), Raheem Brock (DE), Tyjuan Hagler (LB), Jacob Lacey (CB), Antoine Bethea (S), Jerraud Powers (DU) 16 12.38
15 2024 Kwity Paye (DT), Grover Stewart (DE), Zaire Franklin (LB), Jaylon Jones (CB), Nick Cross (S), Kenny Moore (DU) 17 12.18
16 2022 Yannick Ngakoue (DT), DeForest Buckner (DE), Zaire Franklin (LB), Stephon Gilmore (CB), Rodney McLeod (S), Rodney Thomas (DU) 17 11.71
17 2007 Robert Mathis (DT), Raheem Brock (DE), Tyjuan Hagler (LB), Kelvin Hayden (CB), Antoine Bethea (S), Bob Sanders (DU) 16 11.5
18 2003 Dwight Freeney (DT), Montae Raegor (DE), Marcus Washington (LB), Walt Harris (CB), Idrees Bashir (S), Raheem Brock (DU) 16 11.5
19 2010 Dwight Freeney (DT), Eric Foster (DE), Tyjuan Hagler (LB), Kelvin Hayden (CB), Antoine Bethea (S), Jerraud Powers (DU) 16 11.44
20 2012 Robert Mathis (DT), Fili Moala (DE), Jerrell Freeman (LB), Darius Butler (CB), Antoine Bethea (S), Vontae Davis (DU) 16 10.88
21 2017 Barkevious Mingo (DT), Hassan Ridgeway (DE), John Simon (LB), Rashaan Melvin (CB), Matthias Farley (S), Pierre Desir (DU) 16 10.38
22 2011 Robert Mathis (DT), Ricardo Mathews (DE), Pat Angerer (LB), Jacob Lacey (CB), Antoine Bethea (S), Jerraud Powers (DU) 16 10.38
23 2006 Robert Mathis (DT), Raheem Brock (DE), Rocky Boiman (LB), Kelvin Hayden (CB), Mike Doss (S), Dwight Freeney (DU) 16 9.38
24 2016 Kendall Langford (DT), Zach Kerr (DE), Robert Mathis (LB), Darius Butler (CB), Mike Adams (S), Vontae Davis (DU) 16 9
25 2001 Chukie Nwokorie (DT), Ellis Johnson (DE), Mike Peterson (LB), Cory Bird (CB), Chad Cota (S), Chad Bratzke (DU) 16 8.81