| 1 | 2020 | Josh Allen (QB), Zack Moss (RB), Tyler Kroft (TE), Stefon Diggs (WR), Isaiah McKenzie (Flex), Gabriel Davis (Flex), Tyler Bass (K), Corey Bojorquez (P), Ed Oliver (DT), Jerry Hughes (DE), A.J. Klein (LB), Tre'Davious White (CB), Jordan Poyer (S), Taron Johnson (DU) | 16 | 43.1 | 
| 2 | 2022 | Josh Allen (QB), Devin Singletary (RB), Dawson Knox (TE), Stefon Diggs (WR), Gabriel Davis (Flex), Isaiah McKenzie (Flex), Tyler Bass (K), Sam Martin (P), A.J. Epenesa (DT), Ed Oliver (DE), Matt Milano (LB), Dane Jackson (CB), Jordan Poyer (S), Taron Johnson (DU) | 16 | 42.3 | 
| 3 | 2024 | Josh Allen (QB), James Cook (RB), Dalton Kincaid (TE), Mack Hollins (WR), Ray Davis (Flex), Keon Coleman (Flex), Tyler Bass (K), Sam Martin (P), Gregory Rousseau (DT), Austin Johnson (DE), Terrel Bernard (LB), Christian Benford (CB), Taylor Rapp (S), Taron Johnson (DU) | 17 | 42.2 | 
| 4 | 2021 | Josh Allen (QB), Devin Singletary (RB), Dawson Knox (TE), Stefon Diggs (WR), Gabriel Davis (Flex), Zack Moss (Flex), Tyler Bass (K), Matt Haack (P), Ed Oliver (DT), Gregory Rousseau (DE), Matt Milano (LB), Levi Wallace (CB), Micah Hyde (S), Jordan Poyer (DU) | 17 | 41.8 | 
| 5 | 2004 | Drew Bledsoe (QB), Willis McGahee (RB), Mark Campbell (TE), Lee Evans (WR), Eric Moulds (Flex), Travis Henry (Flex), Rian Lindell (K), Chris Mohr (P), Aaron Schobel (DT), Pat Williams (DE), Takeo Spikes (LB), Nate Clements (CB), Lawyer Milloy (S), Terrence McGee (DU) | 16 | 40.8 | 
| 6 | 2023 | Josh Allen (QB), James Cook (RB), Dawson Knox (TE), Stefon Diggs (WR), Gabriel Davis (Flex), Latavius Murray (Flex), Tyler Bass (K), Sam Martin (P), A.J. Epenesa (DT), Ed Oliver (DE), Terrel Bernard (LB), Rasul Douglas (CB), Micah Hyde (S), Christian Benford (DU) | 17 | 40.1 | 
| 7 | 2025 | Josh Allen (QB), James Cook (RB), Dalton Kincaid (TE), Khalil Shakir (WR), Keon Coleman (Flex), Curtis Samuel (Flex), Matt Prater (K), Mitch Wishnowsky (P), A.J. Epenesa (DT), Deone Walker (DE), Terrel Bernard (LB), Tre'Davious White (CB), Cole Bishop (S), Joey Bosa (DU) | 7 | 39.6 | 
| 8 | 2017 | Tyrod Taylor (QB), LeSean McCoy (RB), Charles Clay (TE), Andre Holmes (WR), Zay Jones (Flex), Nick O'Leary (Flex), Stephen Hauschka (K), Colton Schmidt (P), Shaq Lawson (DT), Kyle Williams (DE), Matt Milano (LB), Tre'Davious White (CB), Jordan Poyer (S), Micah Hyde (DU) | 16 | 38.4 | 
| 9 | 2012 | Ryan Fitzpatrick (QB), C.J. Spiller (RB), Scott Chandler (TE), Steve Johnson (WR), Donald Jones (Flex), Brad Smith (Flex), Rian Lindell (K), Shawn Powell (P), Mario Williams (DT), Marcell Dareus (DE), Bryan Scott (LB), Stephon Gilmore (CB), Jairus Byrd (S), Leodis McKelvin (DU) | 16 | 33.9 | 
| 10 | 2016 | Tyrod Taylor (QB), LeSean McCoy (RB), Charles Clay (TE), Justin Hunter (WR), Mike Gillislee (Flex), Marquise Goodwin (Flex), Dan Carpenter (K), Colton Schmidt (P), Jerry Hughes (DT), Marcell Dareus (DE), Lorenzo Alexander (LB), Stephon Gilmore (CB), Corey Graham (S), Nickell Robey-Coleman (DU) | 16 | 33.7 | 
| 11 | 2013 | EJ Manuel (QB), Fred Jackson (RB), Scott Chandler (TE), Robert Woods (WR), Steve Johnson (Flex), Marquise Goodwin (Flex), Dan Carpenter (K), Brian Moorman (P), Mario Williams (DT), Kyle Williams (DE), Kiko Alonso (LB), Leodis McKelvin (CB), Da'Norris Searcy (S), Nickell Robey-Coleman (DU) | 16 | 32.6 | 
| 12 | 2019 | Josh Allen (QB), Devin Singletary (RB), Dawson Knox (TE), John Brown (WR), Cole Beasley (Flex), Frank Gore (Flex), Stephen Hauschka (K), Corey Bojorquez (P), Jordan Phillips (DT), Trent Murphy (DE), Matt Milano (LB), Tre'Davious White (CB), Jordan Poyer (S), Tremaine Edmunds (DU) | 16 | 31.8 | 
| 13 | 2015 | Tyrod Taylor (QB), Karlos Williams (RB), Charles Clay (TE), Sammy Watkins (WR), LeSean McCoy (Flex), Mike Gillislee (Flex), Dan Carpenter (K), Colton Schmidt (P), Jerry Hughes (DT), Stefan Charles (DE), Preston Brown (LB), Ronald Darby (CB), Corey Graham (S), Stephon Gilmore (DU) | 16 | 31.7 | 
| 14 | 2014 | Kyle Orton (QB), Fred Jackson (RB), Scott Chandler (TE), Sammy Watkins (WR), Robert Woods (Flex), Chris Hogan (Flex), Dan Carpenter (K), Colton Schmidt (P), Mario Williams (DT), Marcell Dareus (DE), Nigel Bradham (LB), Corey Graham (CB), Da'Norris Searcy (S), Leodis McKelvin (DU) | 16 | 30.7 | 
| 15 | 2006 | J.P. Losman (QB), Willis McGahee (RB), Robert Royal (TE), Lee Evans (WR), Peerless Price (Flex), Roscoe Parrish (Flex), Rian Lindell (K), Brian Moorman (P), Aaron Schobel (DT), Kyle Williams (DE), London Fletcher (LB), Nate Clements (CB), Donte Whitner (S), Terrence McGee (DU) | 16 | 30.2 | 
| 16 | 1998 | Doug Flutie (QB), Antowain Smith (RB), Jay Riemersma (TE), Eric Moulds (WR), Andre Reed (Flex), Thurman Thomas (Flex), Steve Christie (K), Chris Mohr (P), Ted Washington (DT), Phil Hansen (DE), Sam Cowart (LB), Donovan Greer (CB), Kurt Schulz (S), Bruce Smith (DU) | 16 | 30 | 
| 17 | 1991 | Jim Kelly (QB), Thurman Thomas (RB), Keith McKeller (TE), Andre Reed (WR), James Lofton (Flex), Don Beebe (Flex), Scott Norwood (K), Chris Mohr (P),  (DT), Darryl Talley (DE), Shane Conlan (LB), Nate Odomes (CB), Mark Kelso (S), Cornelius Bennett (DU) | 16 | 30 | 
| 18 | 2002 | Drew Bledsoe (QB), Travis Henry (RB), Dave Moore (TE), Eric Moulds (WR), Peerless Price (Flex), Larry Centers (Flex), Mike Hollis (K), Brian Moorman (P), Ron Edwards (DT), Aaron Schobel (DE), Keith Newman (LB), Nate Clements (CB), Pierson Prioleau (S), Antoine Winfield (DU) | 16 | 29.1 | 
| 19 | 2011 | Ryan Fitzpatrick (QB), Fred Jackson (RB), Scott Chandler (TE), Steve Johnson (WR), C.J. Spiller (Flex), David Nelson (Flex), Rian Lindell (K), Brian Moorman (P), Dwan Edwards (DT), Marcell Dareus (DE), Nick Barnett (LB), Drayton Florence (CB), Jairus Byrd (S), Leodis McKelvin (DU) | 16 | 28.9 | 
| 20 | 2009 | Ryan Fitzpatrick (QB), Fred Jackson (RB), Shawn Nelson (TE), Lee Evans (WR), Terrell Owens (Flex), Marshawn Lynch (Flex), Rian Lindell (K), Brian Moorman (P), Aaron Schobel (DT), Marcus Stroud (DE), Paul Posluszny (LB), Drayton Florence (CB), Jairus Byrd (S), George Wilson (DU) | 16 | 28.6 | 
| 21 | 2005 | Kelly Holcomb (QB), Willis McGahee (RB), Mark Campbell (TE), Lee Evans (WR), Eric Moulds (Flex), Josh Reed (Flex), Rian Lindell (K), Brian Moorman (P), Aaron Schobel (DT), Sam Adams (DE), London Fletcher (LB), Terrence McGee (CB), Lawyer Milloy (S), Nate Clements (DU) | 16 | 27.7 | 
| 22 | 1992 | Jim Kelly (QB), Thurman Thomas (RB), Pete Metzelaars (TE), James Lofton (WR), Kenneth Davis (Flex), Don Beebe (Flex), Steve Christie (K), Chris Mohr (P),  (DT), Bruce Smith (DE), Shane Conlan (LB), Nate Odomes (CB), Henry Jones (S), Mark Kelso (DU) | 16 | 27.6 | 
| 23 | 1990 | Jim Kelly (QB), Thurman Thomas (RB), Keith McKeller (TE), Andre Reed (WR), Kenneth Davis (Flex), James Lofton (Flex), Scott Norwood (K), Rick Tuten (P),  (DT), Bruce Smith (DE), Carlton Bailey (LB), Nate Odomes (CB), Mark Kelso (S), Darryl Talley (DU) | 16 | 27.6 | 
| 24 | 2007 | Trent Edwards (QB), Marshawn Lynch (RB), Robert Royal (TE), Lee Evans (WR), Roscoe Parrish (Flex), Michael Gaines (Flex), Rian Lindell (K), Brian Moorman (P), Aaron Schobel (DT), Kyle Williams (DE), Mario Haggan (LB), Terrence McGee (CB), George Wilson (S), Jabari Greer (DU) | 16 | 27.3 | 
| 25 | 2010 | Ryan Fitzpatrick (QB), Fred Jackson (RB), David Martin (TE), Steve Johnson (WR), Lee Evans (Flex), David Nelson (Flex), Rian Lindell (K), Brian Moorman (P), Chris Kelsay (DT), Kyle Williams (DE), Paul Posluszny (LB), Drayton Florence (CB), Donte Whitner (S), Leodis McKelvin (DU) | 16 | 26.9 |