1958 All Fantasy Team
| Player |
Position |
Team |
Points |
| Johnny Unitas |
Quarterback |
Colts |
94 |
| Jim Brown |
Running Back |
Browns |
98 |
| Raymond Berry |
Tight End |
Colts |
54 |
| Tommy McDonald |
Wide Receiver |
Eagles |
46 |
| Lenny Moore |
Flex |
Colts |
74 |
| Frank Gifford |
Flex |
Giants |
56 |
| Ed Culpepper |
Defensive Tackle |
Cardinals |
12 |
| Jim Katcavage |
Defensive Edge Rusher |
Giants |
14 |
| Joe Schmidt |
Linebacker |
Lions |
32 |
| Charlie Sumner |
Cornerback |
Bears |
38 |
| Jack Butler |
Safety |
Steelers |
36 |
| Ken Konz |
Defensive Utility |
Browns |
31 |
| Steve Myhra |
Kicker |
Ravens |
36 |
| Don Chandler |
Punter |
Giants |
0 |